We have already sent you out to visit Goose Island and take a cold plunge at Lake San Cristobal, so it only makes sense that we eventually fish it. As Colorado’s second-largest natural lake, formed about 700 years ago when the Slumgullion landslide blocked the Lake Fork of the Gunnison River, it is kind of a big deal. It also holds more fish species than any other body of water close to town — rainbow trout, brown trout, brook trout, lake trout, and most excitingly, kokanee salmon. Kokanee are the only salmon you will find in any lake near Lake City and Colorado Parks & Wildlife stocks them regularly. That alone is a reason to bring a rod.
I will admit, as I have said before, that I am not exactly a master fisherman. I am more of a person who uses fishing as an excuse to be near water. But I took the two boys out to the east shore and we gave it a proper go. There was casting. There was enthusiasm. There was also a fairly significant bug distraction — if you have ever tried to fish with kids you know that a caterpillar on a plant will always beat a fish in the water for their attention. I respect that honestly.
HOWEVER. We caught one. Netted it right at the shoreline with the San Juan Mountains sitting in the background like they were posing for a postcard. Hard to beat that.
Lake San Cristobal fishes well from the shore, especially near the outlet and along the east side by Wupperman Campground. If you want to get serious about it — particularly for kokanee and lake trout — you really want to be on the water trolling. Alpine Outfitters runs guided boat trips on the lake and will put you on fish. If you want to gear up or get local advice first, Dan’s Fly Shop on Gunnison Ave has been doing this in Lake City for over 60 years — was the oldest single-owner fly shop in Colorado (great new owner these days). Sportsman’s Fly Shop is another great local option with guides and rentals as well.
You will need a Colorado fishing license if you are 16 or older. Get one before you come or pick one up in town. The lake fishes year-round — even ice fishing in winter if you are into that sort of thing, which apparently a lot of people are.
Also… bring a net.





















































